Skip to content

The Complete Guide to Choosing the Best HCM Software in 2023

Human capital management (HCM) software has become an invaluable tool for HR leaders seeking to manage and empower today‘s dynamic, global workforces. But with countless options to choose from, finding the right platform can feel overwhelming.

This comprehensive guide will demystify HCM software and equip you to confidently evaluate solutions based on your organization‘s unique needs.

What is HCM Software and Why it Matters

Before diving into specific HCM solutions, let‘s quickly cover the basics:

  • HCM software – A category of cloud-based software that helps manage an organization‘s human resources (HR) and workforce needs. It consolidates key HR capabilities into a unified platform.

  • Core HCM capabilities – Talent acquisition, onboarding, learning management, compensation management, payroll, time and attendance tracking, employee data management, performance management, and analytics.

  • Key benefits – Automates manual workflows, provides data-driven insights about people, enhances employee experience, boosts HR efficiency.

  • How it differs from HRMS/HRIS – More strategic focus on managing workforce as a valuable asset vs. just handling basic HR admin tasks. Added capabilities for talent and performance optimization.

The pressure to attract and retain top talent has made HCM solutions a strategic imperative. With the right platform, HR leaders can nurture productivity, foster employee growth, identify high performers, and deliver personalized experiences that drive engagement.

But choosing the best software for your needs can get tricky. The HCM market has exploded with oversubscribed startups and consolidation via acquisitions. Let‘s break down the key considerations.

8 Leading HCM Software Platforms

Today‘s top HCM software platforms leverage cloud delivery, mobile access, consumer-grade interfaces, analytics, and machine learning to create a connected and personalized HR experience. They can consolidate core capabilities or integrate with your existing HR systems.

Here is an overview of 8 top-rated HCM software solutions:

1. SAP SuccessFactors

The market-leading HCM suite from enterprise software giant SAP, SuccessFactors is robust and scalable for global organizations.

Key Strengths

  • Full talent management lifecycle support
  • Powerful workforce analytics
  • Prebuilt integration with SAP ERP
  • Industry-specific capabilities

Great For

Large, complex multinationals seeking an integrated HR/ERP powerhouse

2. Workday

A fast-growing cloud alternative focused exclusively on HCM, Workday enables organizations to optimize their people strategy.

Key Strengths

  • Unified core HCM capabilities
  • Consumer-grade user experience
  • Machine learning to match talent gaps with skills
  • Customizable analytics dashboards

Great For

Large enterprises needing flexible, configurability HR software

3. Oracle Cloud HCM

Part of Oracle‘s next-gen cloud applications suite, Oracle HCM brings proven Oracle HR capabilities into an integrated SaaS platform.

Key Strengths

  • Strong payroll, time tracking
  • Global HR data management
  • Tools to build HR chatbots
  • Seamless transition for existing Oracle HRMS clients

Great For

Mid-to-large size organizations invested in other Oracle cloud solutions

4. UKG Pro

Offering robust workforce management capabilities for hourly and high-volume workforces, UKG Pro specializes in handling complex pay rules, schedules, time tracking and more.

Key Strengths

  • Dynamic scheduling & shift planning optimization
  • Automated pay rules engine
  • Real-time visibility into attendance issues
  • Tools to control labor costs

Great For

Retail, healthcare, manufacturing – any industry managing large hourly workforces

5. BambooHR

A user-friendly system tailored for small and medium businesses, BambooHR makes it easy to consolidate applicant tracking, onboarding, time-off management and reporting in the cloud.

Key Strengths

  • Simple, intuitive interface
  • Integrated applicant tracking
  • Custom on-boarding workflows
  • Generous API and integrations

Great For

SMBs wanting an affordable, lightweight option to get started

6. Namely

Cloud-based HCM platform focused on midsized companies, Namely aims to be an all-inclusive “one-stop shop” for managing people data, payroll, benefits and compliance.

Key Strengths

  • Benefits, payroll, & compliance
  • Single record for all employee data
  • Custom analytics dashboards
  • Integrates with leading benefit carriers

Great For

Mid-market firms needing consolidated HCM with strong payroll/benefits

7. Rippling

A fast-growing startup aiming to unify HCM, IT and financial applications, Rippling takes a different approach – embedding HCM tools like payroll and PTO tracking directly into popular business apps teams already use.

Key Strengths

  • Embeds HR into tools like GSuite, Slack
  • Frictionless cross-app workflows
  • Modern payroll engine with instant payments
  • Free for core HR features

Great For

Fast-growing startups valuing speed and slick end-user experience

8. Paycor

Offering robust payroll, timekeeping, HR and benefits administration for midsized organizations, Paycor focuses on being a complete HCM hub across the employee lifecycle.

Key Strengths

  • Modern self-service and mobile access
  • Custom analytics with benchmaking
  • Integrated recruiting and applicant tracking
  • Streamlined benefits enrollment

Great For

Midsized businesses needing integrated payroll and easy analytics

This overview shows the diversity of today‘s HCM software landscape – ranging from solutions tailored for small business to platforms supporting vast global workforces.

When evaluating options, focus first on core must-have capabilities for your organization before considering specialties like scheduling optimization or machine learning talent analysis.

Now let‘s explore some key considerations when selecting HCM software.

6 Tips for Choosing the Right HCM Software

With the foundational knowledge of what HCM platforms offer, here are six tips to guide your buying decision:

1. Define your critical HR priorities and must-have capabilities upfront

What pain points does your HR organization need to solve? What new capabilities could boost performance? Outline the specific HCM features that align to your top objectives before exploring vendor options.

2. Consider long-term workforce expansion plans

How might your workforce change over the next 5+ years? Predicting future global growth, mergers/acquisitions, or business model shifts will help assess if an HCM platform can scale along with your talent strategy.

3. Compare implementation approaches

Understand how each vendor supports configuration, data migration, integration, and change management. These services can make or break user adoption.

4. Scrutinize mobile, analytics and AI capabilities

Today‘s employees and managers expect consumer-simple mobile access and data-driven insights from HR systems. Evaluate how intuitive and useful each HCM platform‘s mobile experience and analytics capabilities are. Also check if they offer AI features like chatbots for support or skills analysis to spot talent gaps.

5. Talk to an existing customer

Nothing beats inside knowledge. Ask vendors to connect you with a current similar customer to understand pros and cons from real users managing real workforces at scale.

6. Negotiate pricing vigorously

HCM software is not cheap, especially for larger organizations. But significant cost savings can be achieved by negotiating discounts based on number of users, agreeing to longer contract lengths, bundling modules, and highlighting competitor bids. Know your budget and push vendors to meet it.

While assessing HCM software may feel overwhelming initially, asking the right questions will reveal the perfect platform fitting your organization‘s size, industry specialties, technical needs and budget. Partner closely with stakeholders and vendors in your evaluation process.

Trends Shaping the Future of HCM Software

Let‘s now glimpse into the future of HCM technology. Several key trends are elevating solutions beyond traditional HR systems to even more strategic business roles:

AI and Machine Learning – Platforms are infusing automation and intelligence into routine HR tasks like screening applicants, predicting high performers, recommending learning content, and more. The power of AI will grow considerably.

People Analytics – With troves of employee data from across HR systems and business applications, analytics dashboards make it possible to spot trends, identify flight risks, gauge engagement, and continuously refine people initiatives for impact – a major advantage over gut-feel decision making.

Consumerization of HR – Between open jobs apps and always-on engagement from Netflix and Amazon, employee expectations for experience are high. HCM apps now rival consumer apps with sleek interfaces, tailored recommendations, and instant access across devices.

Platform Ecosystem Integration – HCM systems don‘t stand alone. Organizations are carefully connecting HCM data with complementary platforms like IT service management to drive workflows across previously disconnected teams (HR to Facilities to IT).

Continuous Performance Management – Annual reviews are fading away. HCM capabilities like continuous feedback, real-time goal tracking, and regular check-ins (spaced from monthly to quarterly) are the new normal.

The Bottom Line

Let‘s recap what we‘ve covered in this comprehensive guide:

  • HCM software consolidates all HR data, tools and workflows into a unified platform – from talent acquisition to learning to payroll and beyond.

  • Top benefits include workflow automation, data-driven insights, superior employee experience and improved HR efficiency. Productivity and performance gains quickly offset costs.

  • Leading platforms balance broad functionality with industry-specific capabilities to match unique workforce requirements across the talent lifecycle.

  • And most importantly – aligning HCM software with strategic talent objectives has become vital for attracting and optimizing human capital in today‘s ultracompetitive, global business environment.

The stakes are high, but the return on human capital is immense. I hope this guide has armed you to make a confident, forward-looking HCM software selection tailored precisely to your organization‘s needs.

Now go inspire your people and transform HR!